Field Notes
How AI search decides which businesses to recommend
Ask ChatGPT who to hire in your trade and your town. If your business is not in the answer, it is not because the engine dislikes you — it is because the engine could not verify you. AI recommendations are assembled from evidence, and most service businesses have never arranged theirs.
By Chris Maggio, founder ·
The answer is assembled, not ranked
A search engine hands the buyer a list and lets them choose. An answer engine chooses — it names two or three businesses and moves on. That short list is built on the spot from what the engine can verify about each candidate: your Google Business Profile, your listings across directories, your reviews, and your own website.
When we measured our own category — running dozens of buyer-intent questions through ChatGPT — the engines named self-serve software companies again and again, and done-for-you local businesses essentially not at all. Not because those businesses are worse. Because nothing citable described them: no complete profile, no consistent listings, no content that stated their facts in a form an engine could quote. The category existed; the evidence did not.
What the engines read, in order of weight
First, your Google Business Profile: claimed, complete, current — the right category, every service listed, real hours, real photos. It is the record Google keeps about you, and the AI tools lean on it heavily. Second, consistency: the same name, phone number, and service list on your website, your directories, and your socials. Contradictions — an old number on a directory you have never heard of, a dead address — are resolved by trusting you less, everywhere.
Third, reviews: not just the rating, but the flow. A business with forty reviews, the newest from this month, reads as alive; a business with nine reviews from 2022 reads as possibly closed. Fourth, your website’s structure: pages that state what you do in answer-shaped language, with structured data behind them, are pages an engine can quote. A beautiful site that never plainly says what you do, where, and for whom is — to an engine — a rumor.
What to do about it
The prescription is unglamorous, which is why it works: claim and complete the Google profile. Fix the listings until your facts are identical everywhere. Build the review ask into the end of every job, so reviews arrive as a flow instead of a favor. And give your website pages that answer the questions buyers actually ask AI — what you do, who it is for, how it works — in language plain enough to quote.
Then measure the way the engines measure: ask the same buyer questions again, on a schedule, and count how often you are named. Visibility you cannot count is a feeling, and feelings are how businesses stay invisible while believing they are marketed.
This is our Found by AI work, and it starts with a free scorecard: Mia grades your web presence — website, contact paths, reviews, AI visibility, voice — and shows you the gaps in plain language. It is the same audit we ran on ourselves before writing a word of this.
Asked about this
Is AEO different from SEO?
They overlap — a well-structured website helps both — but the target differs. SEO puts you in a list a human scans; AEO (answer engine optimization) puts your name in the single answer an AI gives. Listings consistency and reviews weigh far more with answer engines than they ever did with links.
How long does it take to start getting recommended?
Honestly: weeks, not days. Engines re-read the web on their own schedule, and listings and reviews compound. What can be done immediately is the evidence — profile, citations, structure, review flow — and re-measurement on the same questions so movement shows as a number.
How do I check whether AI recommends my business today?
Start with our free scorecard on this site: Mia reviews your web presence and grades it, including whether the engines can find and describe you at all. Then ask the engines yourself — your trade, your town, the words your buyers use — and see whose names come back.
Start with Talk Live
Do not take our word for any of this — talk to her
Everything in these notes is running live on this website. Tap the button, ask Mia the questions your customers ask, and have her book your working session in the same conversation.
